HHabits & Hustle
← All episodes
Unveiling the Truth23 January 2024

Episode 313: Unveiling the Truth: IDF Soldier Recounts Straightforward Events of October 7th

1Frameworks
12Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take37:30

Gelman Says Ground-Level Warnings Were Pushed Aside

Asked how the attack was missed, Gelman separates the performance of soldiers and observers on the ground from failures higher in the command chain. He says lookout soldiers reported Hamas training before the attack but were told nothing would happen, and argues that mistakes should be examined during the war rather than deferred.

  • Gelman says warning signs moved up the chain of command
  • Lookout soldiers reportedly observed and reported training activity
  • He believes repeated reassurance created institutional complacency
  • He distinguishes ground-level reporting from senior decision-making
  • He argues for learning from mistakes immediately

the soldiers on the ground were doing their job as best as possible the up the chain of command that's where the problem started to…

Yadin Gelman · 39:00

let's quickly see what our mistakes were learn from them and be prepared for the next thing that's going to happen

Yadin Gelman · 40:30
#intelligence#october 7#leadership#warnings
Hot Take2:04:30

Gelman's Closing Case for Peace Beyond Hamas

At the close, Gelman acknowledges polling that showed high Palestinian support for the October 7 attack but cautions that Hamas may influence such results through coercion. He also cites Palestinians criticizing Hamas and argues that removing Hamas could create a real chance for peaceful relations, provided both sides have a willing partner.

  • Gelman cites a poll showing substantial support for the attack
  • He cautions that coercion may influence expressed support
  • He says some Palestinians have told soldiers that Hamas ruined Gaza
  • He distinguishes Hamas from the possibility of Palestinian-Jewish cooperation
  • His stated condition for peace is a willing partner

that may be influenced by Hamas as well that number and they'll tell you to vote but if you don't vote for them they'll kill…

Yadin Gelman · 2:05:00

I really do believe that without Hamas we have a such a good chance for peace and there's it could be such an amazing relationship…

Yadin Gelman · 2:06:30
#peace#hamas#palestinians#israel

Explainer· 1

Explainer04:30

How Israeli Special Forces Test Thinking Under Exhaustion

Gelman describes a selection process combining psychological screening, escalating physical tests, sleep and time deprivation, races, riddles, and fighting drills. The purpose, as he explains it, is not only to measure fitness but to see whether candidates can remain mentally alert while physically pushed to the edge.

  • Candidates undergo mental, psychological, mechanical, and physical testing
  • A week of extreme physical trials is designed to break candidates mentally
  • Removing watches and disrupting sleep creates sustained uncertainty
  • Riddles test cognitive focus during intense exertion
  • Roughly half the initial group is cut after three days

you go back to psych psychological tests and then you do a week of extreme physical tests uh all week where they just try to…

Yadin Gelman · 05:00

they try to break you at all times after two days I had somebody put a gun in my in my in my head like…

Yadin Gelman · 07:00
#special forces#selection#mental toughness#training

Story· 8

Story11:30

Growing Up Alert During the Second Intifada

Gelman recounts growing up in Jerusalem amid suicide bombings and learning to scan buses for possible threats as a child. He says repeated exposure to attacks, loss, and constant warnings shaped the mental toughness and vigilance he later carried into military service.

  • Daily routines could carry an understood risk of attack
  • Gelman remembers scanning buses for threats as a child
  • Families immediately contact people near an attack
  • The community's response was to remain active rather than surrender normal life

I remember as a kid looking for terrorists in my own eyes I'm I'm 10 years old I'm 12 years old and I get on…

Yadin Gelman · 12:00

you'll never let it get to you you'll always keep on going you'll always keep your head up high and that's the mentality that we…

Yadin Gelman · 16:00
#jerusalem#second intifada#childhood#resilience
Story20:30

The Secret Acting Course That Ended a Military Career

Gelman traces his acting ambition to a whispered conversation during a 75-kilometre military hike. Years later, with another seven-year military offer available, he quietly attended acting courses, auditioned for acting school, and told almost nobody until he was accepted.

  • He first voiced the dream of acting at age 19 during training
  • He waited until his final military year to test the ambition
  • His commander allowed him to attend one acting lesson each week
  • He says he was initially terrible but loved the work
  • He declined another seven-year military deal after entering acting school

he says to me so uh uh what's your dream like after the Army and we're 19 years old I mean we just started and…

Yadin Gelman · 21:00

I did the acting course which I was terrible at terrible absolutely terrible and I loved it I loved every second of it

Yadin Gelman · 23:00
#career change#acting#military#risk
Story28:30

The Film Role That Eerily Foreshadowed His Real Injury

Gelman's first film role was an elite commander defending a kibbutz during the 1948 war. In the film, the commander is shot four times on his left side and dies; three years later, Gelman was sent to defend a kibbutz on October 7 and was shot four times but survived.

  • His first film concerned the defence of a kibbutz in 1948
  • He played an elite commander shot four times on the left side
  • His real October 7 mission carried striking parallels
  • Gelman describes the overlap as art and life imitating each other

he gets shot four bullets on his left side the commander which I play and dies on spot it's true story and I played him

Yadin Gelman · 29:00

of me and my team getting sent to kibuts to save the kib from the attack of Kamas and me getting shot for bullets luckily…

Yadin Gelman · 29:30
#acting#kibbutz#coincidence#october 7
Story55:30

His 30th Birthday Ended With an Order to Report to Base

Gelman's girlfriend gathered his military teammates and childhood friends for a surprise glamping birthday weekend on October 6. After calling it the best day of his life, he woke to news of war and a command to reach base immediately; the team left together for the south.

  • His girlfriend organized a surprise gathering for his 30th birthday
  • His whole military team was already together when the attack began
  • The group had stopped music at 11 p.m. and gone to sleep
  • A message from his commander ordered everyone to base
  • His journalist girlfriend continued south as he turned toward the base

on the way to the tent I take my girlfriend I kiss her and I thank her for the best day of my life that's…

Yadin Gelman · 58:00

I check my phone and I have a message from my commander get to the base everyone now I wake up my team we get…

Yadin Gelman · 58:30
#october 7#birthday#mobilization#relationships
Story59:00

The Drive Down the Blood Highway and the First Rescue Point

Gelman describes his team's drive through burned cars and bodies toward Kfar Aza, where fighting was already underway. Unable to contact the team inside without risking friendly fire, they established a medical point and arranged armored extraction of injured civilians, including a badly burned mother and child.

  • The team encountered an armed squad while driving south
  • Gelman says the road was lined with burned vehicles and bodies
  • They could not enter blindly because of friendly-fire risk
  • The team established a medical point outside the kibbutz
  • Armored vehicles brought injured civilians out for treatment

whatever car wasn't on fire just bodies like spilling out of the car and all over the road so that road today is known as…

Yadin Gelman · 1:02:00

what we did was we opened up like a medical Point outside of the kibuts

Yadin Gelman · 1:04:30
#kfar aza#rescue#medical response#october 7
Story1:19:00

Shot and Trapped Under a House for 45 Minutes

Near a reported mass-hostage location, Gelman was shot through his trigger finger and then hit by an AK-47 burst alongside his teammate David. They crawled under a house, guarded both openings, assessed their wounds, and repeatedly lost consciousness while their team fought to reach them.

  • Gelman switched trigger fingers after the first shot
  • A second attacker hit both Gelman and David
  • They took cover beneath the house and guarded two approaches
  • A first rescue attempt left three more soldiers wounded
  • Both men assessed severe wounds while waiting under fire
  • Gelman focused on survival and his girlfriend

he gets one bullet through my uh trigger finger um which is a little shorter now yeah yeah um so he gets it through my…

Yadin Gelman · 1:19:30

I was thinking only of two things first one was of surviving that's what was in my head survival and as cliche as it as…

Yadin Gelman · 1:26:00
#survival#injury#beeri#combat
Story1:27:00

An Improvised Tank Rescue Saved Gelman and His Arm

A soldier from Gelman's unit entered a tank despite never having operated one, drove into the kibbutz, and helped execute a diversion that allowed the team to retrieve Gelman and David. Gelman's nearly detached arm was tied to his vest; later, his girlfriend moved him from an overloaded hospital to Tel Aviv for immediate surgery, preserving the arm.

  • A unit member commandeered a tank without waiting for a green light
  • The tank fired beside windows to avoid potential hostages
  • The team used the diversion to reach the wounded men
  • Gelman's arm was attached mainly by skin and blood vessels
  • His girlfriend arranged transfer when the first hospital could not operate in time

he's never been in a tank in his life before this yeah and as he he went shot he took the team he's like get…

Yadin Gelman · 1:27:30

then she brought an ambulance and put me on the ambulance Brave decision like last second decision sent me to the hospital in Tel Aviv…

Yadin Gelman · 1:35:30
#rescue#tank#surgery#recovery
Story1:31:00

His Journalist Girlfriend Abandoned the News Stand to Save Lives

While Gelman fought nearby, his girlfriend left her field news station, drove through the Nova Festival area, and pulled survivors from bushes under continuing danger. After his call from evacuation, she completed a live broadcast and then went to the hospital, where she pushed for the transfer that saved his arm.

  • She entered the festival area in her private car
  • She searched bushes and transported survivors to medical points
  • Her cameraman followed while the rescue unfolded on live news
  • She and Gelman had not spoken throughout the day
  • She completed her broadcast before joining him at the hospital

she was at the Nova Festival saving lives so she went in with her car drove searched for kids like left her news station abandoned…

Yadin Gelman · 1:31:00

her cameraman is running after her and she's just like pulling people out of the bushes like screaming her name out it's me it's me…

Yadin Gelman · 1:32:30
#nova festival#journalism#civilian rescue#courage

Takeaway· 1

Takeaway1:40:00

Why Gelman Left Recovery to Tell His Eyewitness Story

After a month and a half in hospital, Gelman says he became frustrated by coverage that did not match what he had witnessed. He began speaking at events, schools, and universities, presenting his personal experience along with photographs and videos rather than positioning himself as a detached authority.

  • He watched international news throughout his hospital stay
  • The gap between coverage and his experience drove him to speak
  • His first New York event included David's widow
  • He later spoke to communities, universities, and US officials
  • He frames his contribution as eyewitness testimony rather than abstract opinion

I felt like I couldn't sit aside and and watch these lies just continue going around

Yadin Gelman · 1:40:30

I'm not even talking about my opinion I'm talking about my experience what I've seen with my own eyes

Yadin Gelman · 1:59:00
#advocacy#media#eyewitness#public speaking