Andrew Coates08 November 2024

Episode 396: Andrew Coates: The 3-Bucket Nutrition Hack, Mindful Eating, and TRT After 40

1Frameworks

6Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Self-Mastery5 steps

Three Food Buckets

Keep nutritious favourites, cut mediocre calories, and savour real treats

Read →

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster11:00

Replacement Testosterone Is Not the Same as Extreme Dosing

The conversation distinguishes restoring a major hormone from using supernormal testosterone amounts or other steroids. The distinction is offered as a reason not to collapse every form of hormone use into the same category, while stopping short of medical guidance.

Testosterone is a major hormone naturally present in the body
Replacement and supernormal dosing are materially different concepts
Other steroids should not automatically be conflated with TRT

“testosterone is like a is a major hormone in your body it's different if you're taking HGH I'm not talking about human growth hormone”
Host · 11:00

“if you're taking supern normal amounts of it or other other types of steroids then sure”
Andrew Coates · 11:00

#trt#hormones#steroids

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take09:00

TRT Should Be Discussed Beyond the Steroid Stigma

Coates says testosterone replacement is becoming more common and socially acceptable, but public understanding remains distorted by sensational stories about athletic cheating. He does not present himself as an expert; his point is that stigma should not prevent a more informed and open conversation.

TRT carries a social stigma that can inhibit discussion
Sports scandals shape public understanding of hormone use
Coates explicitly limits his claim because this is not his expertise

“testosterone replacement therapy is becoming more and more common”
Andrew Coates · 09:00

“it's one of those topics that I think most people don't have a good understanding of because we get the the sensationalism over the baseball…”
Andrew Coates · 10:00

#trt#testosterone#stigma

Hot Take13:00

When Population-Level “Normal” May Still Be Unhealthy

Coates says testosterone levels appear to be declining across society and names environmental pollutants and microplastics among possible contributors. His broader point is that a worsening population average should not automatically define a healthy target, just as common metabolic illness does not make it healthy.

Population testosterone levels are described as trending downward
Environmental exposures are suggested as possible contributors
Statistical normality and health are not necessarily the same

“society as a whole we are seeing declining levels of testosterone in the environment for a variety of reasons exposure environmental pollutants microplastics you name…”
Andrew Coates · 13:00

“the definition of what is normal is also going down”
Andrew Coates · 13:00

#testosterone#environment#population health

Explainer· 2

Explainer04:30

Why Standard Restaurant Portions Do Not Fit Every Body

Coates argues that restaurant portions are standardised even though calorie needs vary with body size and muscle mass. He uses average differences between men and women to show why matching another person's serving or alcohol intake can create an unintended calorie surplus.

Average body size and muscle mass affect energy needs
Restaurants generally serve the same adult portions to everyone
Socially normal portions may exceed an individual's needs

“on average women are smaller than men and have less muscle mass okay on average”
Andrew Coates · 04:30

“there's not a women's menu in a men's menu there's a kids menu but the serving sizes of everything we get in society and they're…”
Andrew Coates · 04:30

#portion size#metabolism#restaurants

Explainer12:30

Why a Single Testosterone Number Can Mislead

Asked for a normal range, Coates declines to give a number and highlights measurement complexity. He points to different testing methods, natural fluctuation, and population-level decline as reasons that a simple definition of normal can be misleading.

Testosterone can be measured through different methods
Levels fluctuate rather than remaining fixed
A population average can move even when health outcomes worsen
Coates does not claim expertise on diagnostic thresholds

“I don't have the expertise in knowing what is or isn't normal”
Andrew Coates · 13:00

“also fluctuates really wildly”
Andrew Coates · 13:00

#testosterone#testing#health metrics

Takeaway· 1

Takeaway12:30

Low Testosterone May Matter Beyond Muscle

Coates notes that a less stigmatised discussion could help people consider possible effects beyond physical performance. He specifically names mental health and vulnerability to depression, framing these as reasons to improve access to accurate conversations rather than as a diagnosis.

Hormone discussions extend beyond muscle and athletic performance
Low testosterone may be relevant to mental health
Open discussion can help people understand potential benefits and risks

“we'll see people having more open conversations about it and then people can get the benefits of you mentioned all the things um mental health…”
Andrew Coates · 12:30

#testosterone#mental health#depression