Why Sims Recommends Cool Water, Not Ice, for Women
Sims says icy water can create an excessively strong sympathetic stress response in women, increasing cortisol and mobilizing blood glucose and fatty acids. Around 15°C water provides an initial stimulus without the same intensity and can move toward the vagal, parasympathetic relaxation response people seek.
- Target about 15°C or 56-57°F rather than ice
- Ice can provoke excessive sympathetic drive
- The acute shock can increase cortisol and circulating fuel
- Cool water can support a vagal and parasympathetic response
- Deep breathing can accompany the more manageable exposure
“Ice is too cold and we don't get the same kind of response that men do when we get into ice.”
“So, you don't get that sympathetic.”