Fasting Began as Detachment, Not a Weight-Loss Diet
Sal distinguishes fasting's longstanding spiritual role from its modern marketing as a fat-loss method. He says weight loss mainly follows from eating less and argues that chronic fasting for fat loss can encourage a restrict-then-binge pattern, while acknowledging narrow clinical uses under practitioner supervision.
- Major religious traditions used fasting for detachment rather than weight loss
- Sal attributes fasting-related weight loss primarily to reduced calorie intake
- Calorie restriction and fasting can produce similar studied outcomes
- Restricting intake to a narrow window may encourage binge-restrict behavior
- Severe gut issues may create specific practitioner-supervised exceptions
“Fasting is present in every major world religion, both Eastern and Western. Okay, they it was never to lose weight. It was detachment.”
“If you're doing it for fat loss, it's terrible because what you're encouraging is a binge restrict behavior with yourself.”